maybe you'll let me borrow your heart
This is not going to be a well-written nor a well
thought-out post, this is my appalled reaction to xenophobic harassment to the
celebration of the Philippine Independence Day celebrations back at home. This
is me being utterly ashamed.
I love my country, and I say that to everyone who has asked
me about home while I've been here in the States: Singapore is a great place to
live in, it is safe; the Marina skyline is stunning; it is an affluent,
metropolitan city; it is an eclectic mix of cultures and peoples. And the food,
oh the food. I am proud to be Singaporean, it is my country, my home - it has
given me everything that I have, including this chance to study abroad in
America - and I'm thankful. I make no pretence that Singapore is a perfect
nation - it is not - and I always remark self-deprecatingly that chewing gum is illegal in Singapore to the dismay and
horror of the person unfortunate enough to have that conversation with me. But
I am optimistic, I am hopeful that my generation will bring about change, that
we will create a better, more egalitarian and just tomorrow.
But I just read about the deplorable comments made by my
fellow Singaporeans in opposition to the celebration of the Philippine's
Independence Day being held at the heart of Orchard Road - hateful vitriol
hurled and wielded as misguided weapons of nationalistic pride and solidarity -
and it grieves me.
I have read about race and ethnicity in my sociology texts,
I am informed about the inequality in allocation of resources and life chances
of the different racial groups in Singapore. But being part of the majority at
home, I've never known race prior to coming to and studying in the States. All
of a sudden, race becomes real and reified: one becomes more self-aware even as
some start treating you differently. The way I look and the way I speak all
serve to pigeonhole me as an individual into a certain category, a certain expected
normative role in the minds of others the moment I meet them. All of a sudden,
I was different.
Is this not what we are doing to the Filipinos? Pinoys we
call them, almost derogatorily; foreigners we label and hasten to differentiate
ourselves; competitors who depress our wages, we charge them to justify our
acerbity. These "underlings", "scum", "filth" are
fit to clean our houses, to raise our children, to cook our food but not to
celebrate their Independence Day, to interact with us. We don't want to see
them, nor to hear them; we don't want them on our trains and buses, nor our
malls. They are beneath us.
So who are the people who would befit us superior
Singaporeans? Perhaps the Caucasians. Did we not join in the St. Patrick's Day
festival (wait what did we say about alcohol causing riots again?). Did we not
close off an entire road for the entire weekend for an Irish celebration? Did
the Caucasians not take our jobs and ride our trains and shop at our malls too?
Yes, but these are people that behove our approval and interaction.
I believe that our xenophobia transcends our government's
flaws immigration policy. We seem to venerate whiteness while demeaning
Asian-ness, whatever that is. We approve of the white expatriate while
condemning the darker-toned foreign labour. We credit a white man as the
founding father of Singapore (as if Temasek needed finding) while eliding the
part of being part of the Sri Vijaya Empire from our history books. In so
doing, we have internalised our own racism, we lead a dual consciousness of our
own Asian-ness, both deploring it and distinguishing ourselves as superior to
other "inferior scums".
Singapore, my home, we are altogether better than this. We
are proud of our remarkable achievements over the past 5 decades and we should
be. We pride ourselves on our affluence, but our economic success is built upon
an open, trade-oriented market economy, contingent on our friends and
neighbours. We pride ourselves on our multi-culturalism, but we are being
increasingly intolerant. We aspire to be a great and liveable city, but to be
truly great, we will be judged based on how we treat the weakest and the most
destitute in our society.